India
How the government of India is turning Goa into a coal hub
Nov 13, 2020
Thanks to REMICSCOMICS for permission to publish this cartoon
Thanks to Nihar Gokhale for permission to re-publish his digest of stories about the troubling moves to turn the small Indian province of Goa into a massive coal hub. Numerous large resource companies, including the Adani Group, would be the beneficiaries of this immense transmogrification.

A MEGA PROJECT IS UNDERWAY IN INDIA’S SMALLEST STATE. Goa, straddled by the Western Ghats and the Arabian Sea, will soon be a transport hub for coking coal. The fossil will arrive by ships from Canada, South Africa and Australia to the government port at Vasco da Gama. It will be carried by trucks, barges and trains along Goa’s beaches, paddy fields and hillocks and eventually across the majestic Ghats, through its dense forests and waterfalls and into arid northern Karnataka, where the high-grade coal will be used by factories to convert iron ore into steel.

The project involves more than doubling the amount of coal passing along this chain, and so a number of sub-projects are being executed: vast underwater trenches in the seabed to make it deep enough for massive coal-bearing ships, and a widened network of highways and railways on beaches and in forests.

The execution of this mega project coincided with my beginnings as an environmental journalist five years ago. My years living in Goa coincided with the charged days of protests and public anger against the project.

This page is an effort to put together my work on the subject, and that of the other journalists in Goa who wrote incredible stories on the project.

As I write this in late 2020, the projects continue to be built, stumbling ahead in a haze of protests, court hearings and tribunal cases. So this list is an ongoing project.

2016: My first story, about a National Green Tribunal judgement cancelling the environment clearance given to the project to deepen the seabed. This landmark order set off public hearings that ended up galvanising public opposition to the coal project.

April 2017: I wrote a two-part investigative series for Scroll.in detailing the government’s plans to expand coal handling, the companies who stood to benefit, and how there was pressure on environmental regulators to condone legal violations.

May 2017: Reportage from the environmental public hearings, which turned out to be the longest in history
More stories See all
Scientists to assess ‘death trap’ harbour
Government downplays Adani's violation
Australian Senator slams Adani Group's international record
Warning that 'failed bidding process' will benefit Adani to detriment of Modi's credibility
Will State Bank of India approve a billion-dollar loan for Adani’s Carmichael mine?

September-October 2017: I assisted a team of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation’s investigative program '4 Corners' as they covered the Goa coal projects for their documentary about the Adani Group.

Digging into Adani

October 2017: Indian Express published a multi-part investigative series on the coal projects, written and reported deftly by senior reporter Smita Nair. The series reported issues with the existing coal operations and profiled the people and landscapes affected by the transport.

Coal on move, 25 tonnes a minute, is choking Goa, more is on the way

 

December 2017: Supriya Vohra, who is among my favourite environmental journalists, wrote a two-part series for the Herald about how a new highway to carry coal was wrecking an iconic (and idyllic) Goan village.

LOUTOLIM: "NATIONAL HIGHWAY PROJECT" THREATENS A PEACEFUL VILLAGE

July 2018: The Express series had reported how JSW’s private terminal on the port, which handled the largest quantities of coal for its steel plant in Karnataka, was handling way more coal than what the pollution regulator had allowed it to. The regulator halted coal operations following the report. I wrote this follow-up on how the regulator later condoned these violations.

Goa allows dirty coal handling facility to restart so it can study how bad the pollution actually…

 

August 2018: While doing the above story I found out that while India’s environmental regulation massively evolved from the ’90s up to the present, the JSW coal terminal’s environment clearance was based on old (and more lax) laws.

 

February 2020: After a longish gap, I returned to reporting on the issue in early 2020 when the environment ministry issued clearance to two coal projects. I discovered that the clearance letter was plagiarised from a previous clearance to an unrelated project. So much for the record-breaking public hearings.

 

September 2020: I did an investigative report for Article-14 about 12 new road, railway and power transmission projects that are coming up in the Western Ghats without much scrutiny or regulation. About half of these projects are from the coal project.

To be continued…